Panguan’s Choice (and other Baguazhang Curiosities)

Baguazhang school in 1917, bearing a number of curious weapons
Bulletproof
When the Eight Nation Alliance (Russia, France, Germany, Italy, Austria-Hungary, Britain, Japan and the United States) hit their peak pillaging powers in China, the Qing dynasty was in decline. There were two key tools to the influence of these nations gaining power in China, the first was the opium trade, and the second was their heavy military support, bearing firearms. The insular nature of the Qing dynasty had left it sorely trailing in the scientific advancements that had been going on in the West, which left them open to outsiders raping their resources, through militarily reinforced trade.
There came a critical point when a large group of the Chinese people formed a foreign-influence resistance, under the banner: ‘The 義和拳 (Yìhéquán) [United-in-Righteousness Boxers]’. Some of these boxers (far too many) were convinced by their leadership into thinking that they could call gods / spirits into their bodies and become bulletproof. Historians now refer to this as the Boxer Uprising of 1899-1901 (1) .
Before this gets away from me (too late!), let me bring this back to the point I wasn’t really making very well; this period was the closing chapter on China’s ancient arsenal. Soon after this, China began to accept that spears and shields could no longer compete with the foreign firearms of the time. This was also a key period in the rise of Baguazhang (hereafter: BGZ). Despite having roots and antecedents that go back centuries, BGZ had only really became a fully formed thing a few decades prior to this uprising. So, when BGZ was beginning to be seen in public, ancient weapons such as swords and spears were still prized. The early BGZ pioneers were accomplished fighters that used their art in life and death situations. 董海川 (Dǒng Hǎichuān) -popularly considered the founder of BGZ– and his first BGZ disciple 尹福 (Yǐn Fú), travelled Mongolia collecting taxes for the government, while other students were personal bodyguards or part of teams that protected merchant caravans. It goes without saying then, that they were fully trained in weapon combat.
The Eighteen Weapons
The ancient Chinese had a concept of there being eighteen essential weapons. They could mostly be subdivided into two groups; the 長兵 (Cháng Bīng) [Long Weapons], and 短兵 (Duǎn Bīng) [Short Weapons], but there were also 軟兵械 (Ruǎn Bīng Xiè) [Soft Weapons] – like nine-section chain-whips and rope darts, and 射擊兵器 (Shèjī Bīngqì) [Shooting Weapons] – like bows and crossbows. Which specific weapons made up the eighteen actually varied, it is easier to think of it as a concept, not a specific list written in stone. There was a saying: 「十八般武藝, 十八般兵器」 (Shíbā bān wǔyì, Shíbā bān bīngqì) which translates as “Eighteen kinds of military skills, eighteen kinds of weapons”. Which I take to mean; every weapon requires a unique skill to use. Which leads me to the curious weaponry of Baguazhang.
Deer Horn Knives
In addition to the standard weapons that everyone would have known, like swords, sabres and spears there were always other, stranger ones: Swords with hooks at the ends, sharp metal rings with knife-like barbs on either side of the handles, and other curiosities considered so alien, that the visual effects producer for Star Trek based his Klingon bat’leth on them. This bat’leth-basis weapon was the 鹿角刀 (Lùjiǎodāo) [Deer Horn Knives]. The Deer Horn knives are also known as the 鴛鴦鉞 (Yuānyāngyuè) [Mandarin Duck Blades], and the 雙月 (Shuāng yuè) [Double (Crescent) Moons]. In present day traditional Chinese martial arts, they are close to being the poster weapon for BGZ.

As featured in the film 《師父》 [“The Final Master”] (2)
It is unknown whether actual deer horns were the basis for the original design, but the one thing that is very well known is that they are always used in pairs. BGZ boxing techniques easily map onto fighting with these knives. Common techniques involve catching / blocking and redirecting an opponent’s weapon, then using that close distance to stab them with the pointy ends. When sparring with my plastic replica versions of these I’ve found greater success when sparring against spears and long weapons, where catching is slightly easier to see coming, than against short weapons where they are on more of an equal footing.
The Baguadao
Although it has become strongly associated with BGZ (hence the name used here), the extra-large sized sabre (now popularly called the 八卦刀 (Bāguàdāo) [The Eight Trigram Sabre]) was not unique to the style. Many martial artists from the Beijing area, around the mid to late 19th century – when (& where) BGZ became popular, employed oversized sabres for training. These grand weapons were used as training tools, employing the extra weight and length to develop greater power and control, for application with a regular sized sabre.

The photo on the far left, above is of; 程有信 (Chéng Yǒuxìn), seated and holding an inverted Baguadao. Cheng Youxin was the second son of 程廷華 (Chéng Tínghuá), who is the disciple of Dong Haichuan that most lineages of BGZ can trace their roots back to.
The other two photos to the right of Cheng are of 傅振嵩 (Fù Zhènsōng). Fu was a soldier and one of the Five Northern Tigers, who were so called because of their ability to see-off Southern challengers when they spread the Northern martial arts in the Canton region. It is clear, the man could fight. He learned BGZ from 賈岐山 (Jiǎ Qíshān) a.k.a. 賈鳳鳴 (Jiǎ Fèngmíng), who himself was a disciple of Dong Haichuan. He also studied a number of other styles of martial arts and created a system of martial arts in which his (Fu style) BGZ sits at the top of the syllabus.
As you can see in the photos above, the Baguadao looks like an oversized 牛尾刀 (Niúwěidāo) [Oxtail Sabre], but as it is so big -and a sabre- it can sometimes get confused [in name] with the 大刀 (Dàdāo) [Big Sabre]. The Dadao however, is quite different in appearance, looking more like a butcher’s chopper than an ox’s tail. The picture below shows a Dadao as used in the second Sino-Japanese War [1937–45].

The Bagua Elbow Knives
The 八卦肘刀 (Bāguà Zhǒu Dāo) [Bagua Elbow Knives] have also been known as the 八卦雞肘陰陽銳 (Bāguà Jī Zhǒu Yīnyáng Ruì) [Bagua Rooster Elbows, Paired Points (i.e. Blades)], and the 八卦雞爪陰陽銳 (Bāguà Jī Zhǎo Yīnyáng Ruì) [Bagua Rooster Claws, Paired Blades]. Some explanation about the name(s). ‘Yin Yang’ used here is a reference to them always being used in pairs, and they are ‘Elbow Knives’ because their length ran along the forearms, extending to just past the elbow. (3)

When I played around with a sparring friendly version of these (read: wooden tonfa), I found them fairly easy to work out how to use. The BGZ boxing body-method and movements translated very quickly to weapon sparring. The quickly realised, strong features were the protection to the outer forearms and the stabbing potential at the hand and elbow ends. There is similarity here to the deer horn knives with the paired use and stabbing, but they don’t have the same catching quality, but the outside forearms used for redirection serves as a good substitute.
There are no specific forms with these weapons [The Elbow Knives]. Students learn to interpret Bagua’s empty-hand forms, particularly forms that focus on the use of the elbow, like the Thirteen Elbows, and translate them to this weapon.
Tom Bisio
The Elbow Knives were the weapon of choice for the aforementioned Cheng Tinghua. Cheng’s death returns us to the Boxer Uprising of 1899-1901, where the story goes, that German soldiers tried to forcefully recruit Cheng for a work detail near the spectacles shop he owned in Beijing. When he pulled a knife, they drew their guns and soon after he was shot dead trying to escape over a wall.
The Judge’s Pens
The subject of Cheng’s death ties us nicely to Panguan (4), magistrate of the underworld. 判官 (Pànguān) translates as ‘magistrate’, and in Chinese folkloric depictions of 地獄 (Dìyù) [The Underworld] it is said his primary duty is to check magical records which list a soul’s previous sins.
Long before Matt Damon had his famous choreographed fight scene using a pen in 2002’s “Bourne Identity”, the Chinese had metal versions of writing brushes that they were really fighting with (see pic below).

These were called 判官筆 (Pànguān Bǐ) [Judge’s Pens], but were also known as 筆撾 (Bǐzhuā) [Hitting Pens] and sometimes as the 狀元筆 (Zhuàngyuán Bǐ) [Imperial Scholars’ Pens]. Note: ‘pen’ here actually refers to a writing brush.
Dong Haichuan’s first student Yin Fu (mentioned above) was known for these being his weapons of choice. The Yin style is known for its 牛舌掌 (Niúshé Zhǎng) ‘Ox tongue palm’ hand-shape and the piercing / poking hand attacks. This is likely a direct relation to Yin Fu’s preference for these as weapons crossing over to his bare-hand fighting. In contrast Cheng Tinghua’s style is known for its 龍爪掌 (Lóngzhǎozhǎng) [Dragon claw palm] hand-shape, which makes grabbing and palm strikes easier. A likely crossover from Cheng’s 摔角 (Shuāijiǎo) [Chinese wrestling] background.
Aside from the obvious stabbing potential there are various trapping, locking, and even throwing techniques it is said can be used with them. It’s worth noting that they are not dissimilar in application to the 峨嵋刺 (Éméi Cì) ‘Emei Piercers’. The Emei Piercers look like short metal arrows with arrow tips at both ends and a finger-ring attached halfway down. Apart from being pointy at both ends (unlike the Panguan Bi) and having a ring to support the holding, they served the combatant in a very similar manner.

by modern Chinese artist; 張旺 (Zhāng Wàng) (5)
Founder’s Choice
Confucian philosopher 孟子 (Mèngzǐ) [Mencius] (372-289 BCE), once said (Ch. 1a.); 「制梃可撻」 (Zhì tǐng kě tà) [“With a stick, you can beat (an army)”]. So, to close this article I would like to talk a little about the weapon I associate most with BGZ’s founder, Dong Haichuan: the 七星杆 (Qīxīng Gān) [Seven Star Stick].
The stick itself is made using a specific type of bamboo, but after a little research I came away with three Latin named species which could fit the translated description of the bamboo, and was none-the-wiser as to which one it was (6) . The bamboo is said to have a thin hole through the centre of its length, which would be filled with liquid mercury. This made a light and fast weapon, hit heavy and hard. In addition to poking attacks, the Seven Star Stick excels with whipping strikes. So it comes as no surprise that it is related to, and possibly also known as a 鞭杆 (Biān Gān) [Whipping Stick].
Dong was known to have taught his disciple 宋長榮 (Sòng Chángróng), but apart from Song style you can now also find it in a number of other lineages. Sun style did have a version, but it has been lost. Most versions of the form existent today contain only three out of the original four lines Dong was said to have taught.
Notes
- My introduction greatly over-simplifies the intricate and complex situation that we call the Boxer Uprising, but for some well researched and readable information on the subject I would recommend “The Origins of the Boxer Uprising”, by Joseph W. Esherick (1987), University of California Press.
- Promo pic. for; 《師父》 [Eng title: “The Final Master”] (2016), dir. 徐浩峰 (Xú Hàofēng). Featured in photo: Left (white): 廖凡 (Liào Fán) – with the deer horn knives, Middle (seated); 蔣雯麗 (Jiǎng Wénlì), Right (grey): Unknown.
- ‘Bagua Elbow Knives’, the three Baguadao, the ‘Liu Bin group’ & the ‘unknown dadao soldier’ photos: If you know the copyright holders of these photos please let me know.
- Panguan source: https://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%88%A4%E5%AE%98_(%E7%A5%9E%E7%A5%87)
- The artist is; 張旺 (Zhāng Wàng), a modern Chinese painter, and an associate professor of Nankai University. Here’s his blog-page: http://blog.sina.com.cn/nkzhangwang.
- The description of the bamboo used (source: Joseph Crandall) is; “Sichuan ‘bitter bamboo’ (golden bamboo).” Without more info, any of these are possible candidates;
- Green Dragon Bamboo [Fargesia nitida Sichuan] The Sichuan Bamboo.
- Bitter Bamboo [Indosasa sinica] Native to Northern Laos – NOT Sichuan.
- Golden Bamboo [Phyllostachys aurea] Native to Fujian & Zhejiang – NOT Sichuan.
I suspect it was Golden Bamboo, but am open to being enlightened on the matter.



What’s up! Everything read nicely and the information shared here is in fact, excellent. Keep up the writing.
I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was great.
I don’t know who you are but certainly you are going to be a famous blogger if you aren’t already 😉 Cheers!
Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates. I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite some time
and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with something like this.
Please let me know if you run into anything.
I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.
Thank you for this. It was an amusing account of the subject.
Sorry. Maybe ask Google? Glad you enjoy the articles. Thanks for reading.